IP Cases & Articles

Microplastic detection in marine environments: protecting microplastic monitoring technologies

Microplastic pollution is an increasing focus of research, industry and environmental monitoring. Microplastics are plastic particles smaller than 5mm. Particularly in marine environments, detection of microplastics is important for providing a detailed picture of what the microplastic pollution landscape looks like. Quantification of microplastics in a sample can provide information relevant to assessing its potential effects on marine life, and subsequently the impact on humans though consumption. Detection may also involve identifying the type of plastic, which may in turn help trace the source of pollution, and therefore assist in preventing further contamination.

For businesses developing new detection technologies, however, technical innovation is only half the challenge. Commercialisation of the technology may depend on attracting investment. Once a technique is out in the open, it may be easy to copy, so securing patent protection may help protect revenue from the new technology. The way in which microplastics are collected, detected and analysed can have important consequences for patent strategy. A patent which protects an invention in principle may be less commercially valuable if the protected method is difficult to enforce in the locations the technology is actually being used in.

The challenge of detecting microplastics

One of the fundamental problems with microplastic detection is, perhaps unsurprisingly, size. Smaller particles can be particularly difficult to detect, with greater levels of difficulty being found when detecting particles smaller than 10µm. Additionally, many existing detection methods require extensive sample preparation, including dissection or chemical treatment. Such processes can be slow and time-consuming and, where destructive analysis is required, may be unsuitable for assessing plastic contamination in products which are subsequently intended for sale. This, in combination with the increasing number of emerging AI models directed towards the detection process, leaves considerable scope for technological development.

Who is interested in the technology?

Users of such detection technologies may include researchers and conservation organisations investigating the abundance and distribution of microplastics, along with industry players who may have a commercial interest in measuring microplastics in preparation for likely upcoming regulatory standards, and as a defensive mechanism against public perception and concerns about microplastic pollution in consumer goods (for example, in the fishing industry, and the cosmetics industry).

Those markets may place quite different requirements on the technology. A technique intended for specialist researchers, for example, may accommodate laboratory equipment or a relatively involved workflow. A commercial user testing large numbers of samples may instead place greater value on speed, automation and integration into existing processes. Considering the requirements of the relevant interested sectors and where the relevance of a given technological advancement lies can be key for determining patent coverage. A patent may be more valuable if it covers actions more likely to be performed by a commercial entity rather than merely techniques performed by academic researchers or conservation charities.

Considerations for patent protection

Areas of technical innovation for which patent protection may be sought may concern the physical detection of microplastics, or alternatively may lie further downstream in the workflow, for example in subsequent laboratory analysis or in algorithms and software used to interpret detection data. A microplastic detection system may involve several distinct stages: collecting a sample, preparing it, physically detecting particles and analysing the resulting data. It is worth considering that different stages in the process may also be supplied or performed by entirely different entities, and in different locations. Some stages may take place in the field, others in a laboratory, while software analysis might be supplied by a third-party provider.

When seeking patent protection, it may therefore be inadvisable to treat the complete workflow as a single indivisible invention. While a claim requiring every stage to be performed may provide apparently comprehensive protection, infringement may be more difficult to establish if no single commercial party performs the complete claimed method, or if the process is performed across different territories. Claim protection should be sought around products which are manufactured and distributed together, rather than relying solely on protection for the eventual assembled system.

For a microplastic detection related invention, it can therefore be valuable to ask at an early stage: where does the inventive concept really lie, and who will commercially exploit it? Where possible, it may be beneficial to direct alternative sets of claims towards commercially useful parts of the technology individually, rather than protecting only the complete end-to-end process.

If the innovation is principally a physical detector or another product, the territorial filing strategy may concentrate on countries in which the product is likely to be manufactured and sold, and where competitors are likely to manufacture or sell competing products. Protection may also be desirable in important territories where the invention is likely to be used. It is worth noting that, even where the commercial focus is the physical product, associated method claims can still provide a useful additional layer of protection.

A primarily method-based invention can present challenges for patent protection, particularly for those relating to marine environments. Due to the territorial nature of patent rights, the location at which the claimed technique (particularly if it is a method or process) is carried out is commercially significant when seeking protection.

Collection or analysis performed in remote marine locations raise a potential challenge as territorial waters, wherein patent protection is extended, only extend 12 nautical miles from land. Consequently, it may be worth considering whether useful patent claims can be drafted around steps performed on land, around the operation of a protected detector or other physical product, or around other commercially relevant parts of the process which occur within important patent territories (e.g. on post-processing steps performed at a land-based facility), so as to obtain claims capable of being enforced against meaningful commercial activity.

Scope of protection

While in some cases the marine environment may provide the original motivation for an invention, this environment may not necessarily define the limits of the underlying technology. As microplastics can also be found in air, soil and commercial products, a detector initially developed to analyse seawater could therefore potentially have applications outside marine environments.

If the inventive detection principle operates equally well on an atmospheric, soil, food or manufactured-product sample, unnecessarily defining the claimed technology by reference to a marine environment could surrender commercially useful protection. Broader claims, supported by an appropriately drafted description, may leave open markets which were not the immediate focus when the technology was first developed.

Strategic tips

For developers of microplastic detection technology, a good patent strategy should therefore start with the commercial workflow rather than with the patent claim itself.

Before filing, it is worth mapping out:

  • which part of the detection process contains the inventive contribution;
  • whether protection can be obtained for a physical product as well as a method;
  • who is expected to make, sell and use each part of the technology;
  • where those activities are likely to take place;
  • whether different stages will be performed by different organisations; and
  • whether the underlying invention has useful applications outside marine environments.

Such an analysis can help ensure that claims protect commercially meaningful activity rather than merely describing the complete scientific process.

Microplastic detection presents a particularly good example of why patent strategy needs to follow both the technology and the market. As detection moves from research towards wider commercial use, considering these questions early can make the difference between simply obtaining a patent and obtaining patent protection that is genuinely useful to the business.

Patent newsletter Latest edition
Patent newsletter Latest edition